Chapter 18: The Miswak Tradition

Of all the botanical oral health traditions I've watched humans develop, none is more elegant than the miswak.

It's a twig. That's all it is—a twig from a particular tree, chewed and frayed at one end to create a brush. No manufacturing required. No supply chain. No packaging. Just a person, a tree, and seven thousand years of accumulated wisdom.

And yet this simple twig contains, by some remarkable convergence of evolution and human observation, nearly everything a tooth could need.

The Tree: Salvadora persica

The miswak tree—Salvadora persica, also known as the toothbrush tree, arak, or peelu—grows across the Middle East, Africa, and South Asia. It's a hardy shrub or small tree that thrives in arid conditions, producing small fruits and fibrous branches that humans figured out, very long ago, were useful for cleaning teeth.

The earliest archaeological evidence for toothbrush-like implements dates to ancient Babylon, around 3500 BCE.¹ The miswak specifically appears in ancient Egyptian texts and has been used continuously across the Arabian Peninsula, the Indian subcontinent, and much of Africa for millennia.

In Islamic tradition, the miswak holds special significance. The Prophet Muhammad reportedly recommended it, and numerous hadith (sayings) endorse its use. This religious endorsement helped preserve and spread the practice across the Islamic world, where it remains common today. Hundreds of millions of people still use miswak as their primary oral hygiene tool.

The Chemistry: Nature's Toothpaste

Here's where the miswak becomes remarkable. When you analyze the chemical composition of Salvadora persica twigs, you find a compound pharmacy:

Abrasives and Cleaners

Silica (approximately 1%): This provides mild abrasiveness for mechanical plaque removal. The silica particles in miswak are similar in function to the silica used in many commercial toothpastes.

Sodium bicarbonate (naturally occurring): Yes, the same baking soda we've discussed throughout this book. The plant actually contains it. pH buffering, built in.

Sodium chloride (naturally occurring): Salt, for osmotic effects and mild antimicrobial action.

Antimicrobial Compounds

Benzyl isothiocyanate (BITC): This is the star compound. Isothiocyanates are the pungent chemicals responsible for the bite of mustard, horseradish, and wasabi.² In miswak, BITC concentrations around 10 μg/mL have been measured—enough to have significant antimicrobial effects.

BITC has demonstrated activity against:

• Streptococcus mutans (the primary cariogenic bacterium)
• Streptococcus faecalis
• Porphyromonas gingivalis (periodontal pathogen)
• Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans (periodontal pathogen)
• Candida albicans (oral fungus)

The mechanism involves disruption of bacterial enzymes and membrane function.

Salvadorine: An alkaloid unique to Salvadora persica, with reported antimicrobial properties.

Trimethylamine: A nitrogen-containing compound that raises pH (alkaline) and has antimicrobial effects.

Sulfur compounds: Various sulfur-containing molecules with antimicrobial activity.

Mineralization Support

Fluoride (8-22 ppm): The plant naturally contains fluoride at concentrations comparable to some fluoridated water supplies.³ This was discovered relatively recently and adds another mechanism of caries protection.

Calcium: Present in forms that may contribute to remineralization, though the extent is debated.

Chloride ions (approximately 0.5%): High chloride concentrations may help prevent calculus (tarite) formation.

Gum Health Compounds

Vitamin C: Supports connective tissue health and wound healing in gum tissue.

Tannins: Astringent compounds that may help tighten and tone gum tissue.

Resins: May provide a protective coating effect.

Other Notable Compounds

Volatile oils: Contribute to fresh breath and may have antimicrobial effects.

Saponins: Natural surfactants that help with cleaning.

Flavonoids: Antioxidant compounds.

This isn't one or two active ingredients—it's a complex, synergistic mixture that addresses multiple aspects of oral health simultaneously. The plant evolved these compounds for its own defense; humans discovered they happen to be exactly what teeth need.

The Evidence

The World Health Organization, in a 1987 consensus report, acknowledged that miswak use is a valid alternative to conventional toothbrushing for oral hygiene.⁴ This was an unusual endorsement of a traditional practice by an international health authority.

Since then, numerous studies have examined miswak more rigorously:

Comparative Studies vs. Toothbrushing

Multiple studies have compared miswak users to toothbrush users:

Plaque reduction: Studies consistently show that miswak users have comparable or superior plaque control compared to toothbrush users. A frequently cited study by Al-Otaibi et al. (2003) found that miswak users had lower plaque scores than toothbrush users.

Gingivitis: Similar findings—gingival health in miswak users is generally equivalent to or better than toothbrush users.

Microbial effects: Studies measuring S. mutans counts typically show lower levels in miswak users, suggesting the antimicrobial compounds have real effects.

Mechanism Validation

In vitro studies have confirmed antimicrobial activity:

• Miswak extracts inhibit S. mutans growth
• Biofilm formation is reduced in the presence of miswak compounds
• The effects are dose-dependent and genuine, not just folk belief

Limitations of the Evidence

To be fair, I should note:

Study quality varies: Many miswak studies have methodological limitations—small sample sizes, short duration, variable technique assessment.

Cultural confounding: Miswak use is embedded in cultural and religious practices that may include other health behaviors (dietary patterns, frequency of use, etc.).

Interproximal cleaning: Some researchers suggest miswak may be less effective for interproximal (between-tooth) cleaning compared to floss.

Fresh vs. dried: Fresh miswak twigs appear more effective than dried or processed products, but most studies don't clearly specify which was used.

The Systematic Review Conclusion

A 2003 systematic review in Oral Diseases by Wu et al. concluded:⁵

"The available evidence suggests that miswak use is at least as effective as toothbrushing for reducing plaque and gingivitis."

This is a notable conclusion—traditional wisdom validated by systematic evidence review.

How to Use Miswak

If you want to try miswak, here's the traditional method:

Preparing the Twig

1. Obtain fresh miswak sticks. These are available online and at Middle Eastern or South Asian groceries. Look for sticks that are light brown, not dried out or moldy.

2. Soften the end. Soak one end in water for a few hours, or chew it gently to soften. Some people peel away about half an inch of bark first.

3. Create the brush. Continue chewing/fraying the softened end until it separates into bristle-like fibers. This takes a few minutes of gentle chewing and pressing.

4. The brush forms. You now have a natural toothbrush—a fibrous head attached to a handle.

Using the Miswak

1. Hold like a pen. Grip the stick so the bristle end extends from your hand.

2. Brush teeth and gums. Use gentle, short strokes. Cover all surfaces—outer, inner, chewing surfaces.

3. The taste. Fresh miswak has a slightly bitter, spicy, distinctive taste. This is the active compounds. It's not unpleasant once you're used to it.

4. Clean the tongue. The frayed end can also be used to scrape the tongue.

5. Rinse. Rinse mouth with water when finished.

6. Maintain the brush. After each use, rinse the bristles. Cut off the used portion (about ¼ inch) daily to expose fresh fibers. A single stick can last about a week.

Tips for Beginners

• Start with short sessions while you develop technique
• Keep the stick moist when not in use (wrap in damp cloth or store in refrigerator)
• Don't share sticks—each person should have their own
• If the bristles become too soft or mushy, cut them off and fray fresh fibers

Commercial Miswak Products

The traditional twig isn't the only way to access miswak benefits. Commercial products have emerged:

Miswak Toothpaste

Various brands incorporate Salvadora persica extract into toothpaste formulations. These may provide some of the antimicrobial benefits, though the concentrations and processing vary. Read labels—some products contain significant extract, others just use the name for marketing.

Peelu Products

The brand "Peelu" (named for one of miswak's common names) produces gum, toothpaste, and other products containing Salvadora persica. Combined with xylitol, Peelu gum provides a convenient way to get miswak exposure between brushings.

Miswak Powder

Dried, powdered miswak can be added to homemade toothpaste or used directly. The processing may reduce some volatile compounds, but the mineral and stable antimicrobial components should remain.

Evaluation

Commercial products are probably less effective than fresh miswak for several reasons:

• Processing may destroy some active compounds
• The mechanical brushing action of the twig is absent
• Concentrations vary and are often not standardized

However, they're more convenient than sourcing and preparing fresh twigs, and they likely provide some benefit. For most people in Western countries, a combination approach might work best: fluoride toothpaste for primary brushing, miswak products as adjuncts, and perhaps occasional traditional miswak use for those interested in the full experience.

The Tooth Fairy's Perspective

I remember when miswak use was universal across its native range. Every traveler carried a twig. Bazaars sold bundles of them. Children learned the technique from their parents.

The British, during their colonial period, were dismissive. A twig? How primitive. They brought toothbrushes with imported bristles and manufactured powders. Progress, they called it.

But I noticed something: the people who kept using miswak kept more of their teeth.

It took over a century for science to circle back and validate what those cultures never forgot. The WHO endorsement in 1987. The clinical studies in the 1990s and 2000s. The isolation and identification of benzyl isothiocyanate and the other active compounds.

The knowledge was never lost—it just wasn't listened to. Millions of people kept using miswak despite being told it was backward, primitive, superstitious. They trusted their tradition over outside authorities. They were right.

This is why I included miswak first in this botanical section. It's not just an effective oral health tool—it's a reminder that traditional wisdom deserves respect, not dismissal. That when a practice persists for seven thousand years across diverse cultures, there's probably a reason.

And it's a twig. A simple, elegant, effective twig.

Sometimes the old ways are the good ways.

---

---

1. History of dental treatments — Wikipedia. Archaeological evidence suggests tooth cleaning implements were used in ancient Babylon and Egypt. ↩

2. Isothiocyanate — Wikipedia. A class of pungent, sulfur-containing compounds found in cruciferous vegetables and the mustard family, with documented antimicrobial properties. ↩

3. Hattab, F. N. (1997). Meswak: The natural toothbrush. Journal of Clinical Dentistry, 8(5), 125-129. Analysis of Salvadora persica revealed fluoride concentrations of 8-22 ppm. ↩

4. World Health Organization. (1987). Prevention of oral diseases. WHO Offset Publication No. 103. Geneva. Acknowledged miswak as a valid oral hygiene tool. ↩

5. Wu, C. D., et al. (2001). Chewing sticks: timeless natural toothbrushes for oral cleansing. Journal of Periodontal Research, 36(5), 275-284. Systematic review finding miswak at least as effective as toothbrushing. ↩